Companion planting
Companion planting, with the evidence
Does companion planting work? Sometimes, for particular pests, crops and settings. Across hundreds of experiments, mixed plantings tend to have fewer pests and more pest predators, but companions can also compete with the crop, and many popular pairings have never been tested. This guide sets out which pairings the evidence supports, how strongly, and where it doesn’t.
Companion planting complements good care, regular checks and physical protection. Encouraging helpful insects supports a natural balance but doesn’t guarantee pest control, and companions can compete with your crop, so give them room.
How the evidence is rated
- Supported by research
- Peer-reviewed studies or extension trials show an effect.
- Supported by horticultural guidance
- Recommended by the RHS or similar horticultural bodies.
- Limited evidence — specific conditions
- Research exists, but only under narrow conditions.
- Traditional practice — limited evidence
- Folklore, with little or no evidence.
How companions help
- Pest deterrence
- Scent or presence that makes a crop harder for a pest to find.
- Food for pest predators
- Flowers or shelter for insects that eat pests. Helps the balance; no guarantee of control.
- Pollinator support
- Flowers that feed bees and other pollinators. Supports fruit set; does not control pests.
- Physical protection
- Mesh or covers that stop pests reaching the crop.
- Care and monitoring
- Regular checks and good growing conditions, so problems are caught early.
- Trap crop
- A plant pests prefer, grown to draw them away from the crop. It gathers pests rather than killing them, so it needs checking.
- Sharing space
- Plants with different shapes, roots or timing share a bed with little competition. Not pest control.
What the research says overall
- Across 552 experiments, crops grown with other plants generally had fewer pests, more natural enemies and less crop damage than crops grown alone. Ecological Applications
- Flower strips improved pest control in neighbouring crops by about 16% on average. Effects on pollination and yield were more variable, and pollination benefits fell quickly with distance. Ecology Letters
- Across cabbage intercropping studies, companions cut pest injury by 48% on average but also cut cabbage yield by 7%: companions can compete with the crop. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment
- In a 2024 UK gardeners’ trial, chard grown with leeks cut marketable leek yield by 69% without a significant reduction in allium leaf miner. Garden Organic
- UK government guidance funds companion crops as one part of integrated pest management, for example as trap crops or habitat for natural predators. Defra / GOV.UK
Supported by research
French marigolds with Tomatoes
May slow the build-up of glasshouse whitefly on tomatoes.
How: Grow a few marigolds among or beside your tomatoes from when the tomatoes go in, in the same greenhouse or bed. Keep them in full sun and deadhead to keep them going.
Worth knowing: It slows whitefly rather than stopping it, and isn’t a rescue for plants already infested. Keep checking under tomato leaves.
What the evidence says
- Marigolds grown alongside glasshouse tomatoes from the seedling stage slowed glasshouse whitefly population development; limonene released by the marigolds repelled whiteflies. Introducing marigolds after significant whitefly build-up was much less effective. PLOS ONE
- The study is the first scientific test of this long-used gardener technique, and found it did not affect the quality of the tomatoes. Newcastle University
- French marigolds grow in full sun, in moist but well-drained or well-drained soil, and flower from summer into early autumn. RHS
Limits of the evidence
- Tested against glasshouse whitefly (Trialeurodes vaporariorum) on tomatoes under glass. Other pests and outdoor beds were not the subject.
- Works as prevention from the start of the crop, not as a cure for a heavy infestation.
- French marigolds are tender: plant out only after frost risk has passed.
- This is specific to whitefly. It doesn’t mean marigolds repel pests in general.
Sweet alyssum with Lettuce
Its flowers feed hoverflies, whose larvae eat aphids on lettuce.
How: Plant a few alyssum plants along the edge of, or dotted through, your lettuce. Keep them close: in UK trials the effect faded with distance.
Worth knowing: Hoverflies arrive once alyssum flowers, so it helps summer lettuce more than an early spring crop. Some aphids will still appear.
What the evidence says
- Growing alyssum with lettuce has been shown to reduce aphid populations, because its nectar and pollen attract natural predators of aphids. RHS
- Over nine years of organic lettuce production, alyssum strips attracted hoverflies and gave good aphid control without reducing marketable lettuce yield. eOrganic (USDA-ARS research)
- Adding alyssum transplants among lettuce, rather than replacing lettuce, was the more space-efficient way to intercrop. Biological Control
- In UK field lettuce, wildflower strips reduced aphids on nearby lettuce in June and July, with less effect in August and September. The reduction was greatest closest to the strips, with little effect at 10 metres. Bulletin of Entomological Research
- Sweet alyssum is a low, bushy annual with honey-scented flowers throughout summer, grown in light, well-drained soil in full sun and sown where it is to flower in spring. RHS
- It can also be sown indoors in March and planted out in May. RHS
- Sweet alyssum strips in Quebec lettuce fields attracted 16 hoverfly species, 14 of which have aphid-eating larvae. Ecology and Evolution
Limits of the evidence
- Most alyssum research is from commercial fields in California and Quebec. The UK trial used mixed wildflower strips, not alyssum alone.
- The benefit is local and seasonal: strongest right beside the flowers and in early to mid summer.
- Hoverflies are wild and come and go. Encouraging them does not guarantee aphid control.
Borage with Strawberries
Borage draws bees and other pollinators to strawberry flowers. In UK gardens and allotments, strawberries next to borage gave about a third more fruit.
How: Plant one or two borage plants right beside your strawberries, in full sun. Closer is better: in the study, the benefit fell with distance.
Worth knowing: Borage grows 50–70cm and self-seeds, so keep it where it won’t shade your strawberries. The earliest strawberry flowers may open before the borage does.
What the evidence says
- In researcher-led trials and citizen science across UK gardens and allotments, strawberries companion-planted with borage produced 35% more fruits and 32% more yield by weight, with better market quality. Yield and pollinator numbers declined with distance from the borage. Ecological Entomology
- On six Scottish strawberry farms, crops next to sown wildflower strips had 25% more pollinator visits on average. Ecology and Evolution
- In Swiss strawberry fields, wildflower strips increased wild bee visits and pollination near the strips, but seed set across the whole field did not increase. Ecology and Evolution
- Pollinating insects love borage flowers. It is an annual that self-seeds and grows to around 50–70cm in full sun. RHS
- Many flowering plants host common green capsid or European tarnished plant bug, which damage strawberries even at low numbers. AHDB
Limits of the evidence
- One UK study. Your results will depend on local pollinators and weather.
- The benefit is local: plants right next to the borage gained most.
- Flowers can bring pests as well as pollinators: AHDB warns that many flowering plants host capsid bugs, which damage strawberries.
Wildflower mix with Lettuce
A strip of wildflowers beside lettuce reduced aphids nearby in a UK trial, by feeding their natural enemies.
How: Sow a strip of wildflowers right along the edge of your lettuce bed. The effect was strongest closest to the flowers.
Worth knowing: A wildflower strip takes space and a season to establish. In the trial it helped most in June and July, and little 10 metres away.
What the evidence says
- In UK field lettuce, wildflower strips reduced aphids on nearby lettuce in June and July, with less effect in August and September. The reduction was greatest closest to the strips, with little effect at 10 metres. Bulletin of Entomological Research
- Annual wildflower mixes are sown in early to mid spring or early autumn and flower in summer. RHS
Limits of the evidence
- A commercial-scale field trial; a garden strip is much smaller.
- Aphid numbers fell but weren’t eliminated; keep checking your lettuce.
White clover with brassicas
Low clover around brassicas makes them harder for cabbage root fly and other specialist pests to find.
How: Sow white clover thinly between and around your brassicas, at or just after planting, and keep it low and clear of the stems.
Worth knowing: Clover competes for water and nutrients: across studies, companions cut cabbage yields by about 7% on average while cutting pest damage by about half.
What the evidence says
- Interplanting with clover has been shown to reduce cabbage pests. RHS
- Specialist brassica pests need several landings on host plants before laying eggs; landing on non-host plants interrupts this. Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata
- Across studies, cabbage intercropping cut pest injury by 48% but yield by 7%. Living mulches were linked to lower pest injury, and low-growing companions sown at or after planting competed least. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment
- Legume green manures such as clovers fix nitrogen; crimson clover, for example, is sown from March to August. The page doesn’t give sowing times for white clover. RHS
Limits of the evidence
- Expect less damage, not none: mesh or collars are still the reliable protection against cabbage root fly.
- Competition is the main cost; keep clover away from young transplants’ stems.
Applies to: Cabbages, Cauliflower, Calabrese, Sprouting broccoli, Kale, Brussels sprouts.
Turnip rape with brassicas
A border of turnip rape draws flea beetles away from young brassicas.
How: Sow a strip of turnip rape so it’s growing before your brassicas go in. Leave 3–6 metres of bare ground between them if you can.
Worth knowing: The trap gathers flea beetles rather than killing them, so check it. Small gardens may not have room for the gap; mesh is the simpler protection.
What the evidence says
- In UK trials, flea beetles damaged a turnip rape border far more than cauliflower planted in the same position. A 3–6 metre gap between trap and crop reduced damage to cauliflower, and in open fields the trap crop reduced damage, significantly so later in the season when pest numbers were higher. Insects
- Flea beetles are most active in spring and summer and chiefly damage seedlings; insect-proof mesh or fleece prevents the damage. RHS
Limits of the evidence
- Tested with cauliflower; other brassicas are attacked by the same beetles but weren’t in the trial.
- A managed technique: the trap only helps if it stays more attractive than your crop.
Applies to: Cabbages, Cauliflower, Calabrese, Sprouting broccoli, Kale, Brussels sprouts.
Garlic with Aubergines
Rows of garlic between aubergines cut two-spotted spider mite damage in a two-season field trial.
How: Grow garlic in rows alongside your aubergines. In the UK it needs to be planted in autumn or February to be growing when aubergines go in.
Worth knowing: The trial was outdoors abroad. UK aubergines are usually under glass, and garlic is lifted in early summer, so the overlap may be short.
What the evidence says
- In 2019 and 2020, all three eggplant–garlic row designs had fewer spider mite eggs and mobile stages than eggplant alone; the spider mite damage index was 8–12% in intercrops against 37–40% in sole eggplant, and crop yield improved. Experimental and Applied Acarology
Limits of the evidence
- One field study outside the UK, against one pest.
- Timing in UK gardens may not match the trial.
Supported by horticultural guidance
Calendula with Lettuce
Open flowers that feed adult hoverflies. Many hoverfly larvae eat aphids.
How: Grow a small patch right beside your lettuce, in sun or light shade. Deadhead to keep flowers coming.
Worth knowing: Self-seeds readily, so pull unwanted seedlings. The link to fewer aphids on your lettuce specifically is not proven.
What the evidence says
- Hoverflies prefer open flowers with accessible pollen and nectar; English marigold (Calendula) is one of the RHS’s suggested plants. Approaching half of British hoverflies are aphid predators as larvae. RHS
- Calendula is an easy hardy annual that flowers from summer through to early autumn, best in full sun but tolerating light shade, and often self-seeds. RHS
- Hardy annuals such as pot marigolds can be sown in September and October; autumn sowings may need protection from hard frosts but flower earlier than spring sowings. RHS
- In UK field lettuce, wildflower strips reduced aphids on nearby lettuce in early to mid summer, most strongly closest to the strips. Bulletin of Entomological Research
Limits of the evidence
- General advice to support hoverflies. Calendula itself hasn’t been trialled with lettuce. It complements, rather than replaces, checking your plants.
Onions with Carrots
Carrots root deeply and onions shallowly, so they can share a bed with little competition. Any carrot fly protection is uncertain.
How: Sow or plant them in alternate rows at about the same time. To protect carrots from carrot fly, cover them with insect-proof mesh.
Worth knowing: Don’t rely on the onions to keep carrot fly away: trials have given inconsistent results.
What the evidence says
- Onions grown with carrots were thought to confuse carrot root fly, but trials have shown inconsistent results; mesh or fleece is more likely to give consistent control. Deep-rooting carrots and shallow-rooting onions can grow side by side without too much competition. Garden Organic
- Deep-rooted carrots planted among shallower-rooted onions use space efficiently, with little competition. The RHS says the scent of onions has been claimed to make it harder for carrot fly to find carrots. RHS
- RHS research found that completely covering carrots with insect-proof mesh is more effective than a barrier. RHS
- Mixed cropping reduced carrot fly attack only under narrow conditions: young onions at high onion-to-carrot density. The effect was virtually lost once the onions began to bulb. Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata 36:159–167
Limits of the evidence
- Treat any carrot fly effect as traditional practice with limited, inconsistent evidence.
- Insect-proof mesh is the reliable protection for carrots.
Borage with Courgettes and Squash and pumpkins
Its flowers are loved by bees. Courgettes, squash and pumpkins need insects to pollinate their female flowers.
How: Grow a plant or two at the edge of the bed, in full sun. In cool spells, hand-pollinate as well.
Worth knowing: Courgettes and squash are vigorous and can smother neighbours, and borage grows 50–70cm and self-seeds, so give both room. No trial shows it raises their yields.
What the evidence says
- Poor fruit set in courgettes, marrows, pumpkins and squash is often caused by too little pollinating insect activity in cold or poor weather; hand pollination can help. RHS
- Pollinating insects love borage flowers. It is an annual that self-seeds and grows to around 50–70cm in full sun. RHS
- Across studies, the effect of flower strips on crop pollination and yield was variable, and pollination benefits declined quickly with distance from the flowers. Ecology Letters
Limits of the evidence
- Borage supports pollinators in general. A UK garden study found it raised strawberry yields, but courgettes and squash haven’t been tested.
Radishes with Parsnips
Quick radishes sown with slow parsnips mark the row and are pulled long before the parsnips need the space.
How: Sow a few radish seeds thinly along the parsnip drill, or between the rows, on the same day. Pull the radishes as soon as they’re ready.
Worth knowing: This is about using space and seeing where slow parsnips are, not pest control. Don’t let the radishes crowd the parsnip seedlings.
What the evidence says
- Radishes can be used as row markers for slow-germinating crops such as parsnips and onions: they germinate quickly, marking the row, and are harvested before they can hinder the main crop. Fast salad radishes also fill gaps between slower crops. RHS
Limits of the evidence
- Space and timing only. It doesn’t protect parsnips from pests.
Radishes with Sweetcorn and Brussels sprouts
Quick radishes can use the gaps between young, widely spaced plants and be pulled before those plants fill the space.
How: Sow a short row of radishes between the young plants when you plant them out, and pull them within about a month.
Worth knowing: It only works while the main crop is small: once it fills out, it shades the gaps. Space use only, not pest control.
What the evidence says
- Fast-maturing plants such as lettuce and radish can be intercropped between bigger, slower plants like Brussels sprouts or sweetcorn, which are planted at wide spacings they fill when mature. The small plants are harvested before the big ones overshadow them. RHS
Limits of the evidence
- Space and timing only. It doesn’t protect the main crop from pests.
Lettuce with Sweetcorn and Brussels sprouts
Fast lettuce can use the gaps between young, widely spaced plants and be cut before those plants fill the space.
How: Plant or sow lettuce between the young plants when you plant them out, and harvest it before the main crop shades it.
Worth knowing: It only works while the main crop is small. Space use only, not pest control.
What the evidence says
- Fast-maturing plants such as lettuce and radish can be intercropped between bigger, slower plants like Brussels sprouts or sweetcorn, which are planted at wide spacings they fill when mature. The small plants are harvested before the big ones overshadow them. RHS
Limits of the evidence
- Space and timing only. It doesn’t protect the main crop from pests.
French beans with Sweetcorn
Sweetcorn gives climbing French beans something to climb, so the two share one patch: part of the “three sisters”.
How: Plant sweetcorn in a block about 45cm apart. Once it’s about 30cm tall, sow or plant a climbing French bean at the base of each plant.
Worth knowing: Use climbing French beans: runner beans are too vigorous for the corn. Beans fix nitrogen, but how much reaches the corn while both are growing varies and is often small. Expect a shared patch, not a bigger corn crop.
What the evidence says
- Plant a block of sweetcorn 45cm apart and, once it is about 30cm tall, sow climbing beans at the base of each plant. Climbing French beans work well; runner beans can be too vigorous. RHS
- The three sisters system of maize, pumpkins and climbing beans is an example of companion plants giving physical support: the maize supports the beans. RHS
- In field plots (not in the UK), maize–bean and maize–bean–squash mixtures yielded more per area than the crops grown separately, partly because their roots explore different parts of the soil. Annals of Botany
- Across 74 studies, the share of a legume’s nitrogen passed to a neighbouring crop while both grow ranged from under 1% to about 53%, depending strongly on conditions; fertiliser reduced it. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 401:110295
Limits of the evidence
- The yield research is from overseas field trials, not UK gardens.
- Nitrogen passed to the corn during the season is variable and often small. Leaving bean roots in the soil after harvest adds more.
Squash and pumpkins with Sweetcorn
Squash or pumpkin leaves cover the ground between sweetcorn, shading out weeds and holding moisture in the soil.
How: Plant one squash or pumpkin per square metre of the sweetcorn block, at about the same time as the beans.
Worth knowing: Squash is vigorous, so give each plant about a square metre. Keep weeding until it covers the ground, and water all season.
What the evidence says
- Pumpkins or squashes shade the soil and hold moisture with their large leaves, and once established they block weed growth. Plant them at the same time as the beans, one per square metre of the scheme. RHS
- In the three sisters, the squash uses the space between the maize plants, shading the soil and suppressing weeds. RHS
Limits of the evidence
- Ground cover and space use, not pest control.
Limited evidence — specific conditions
Basil with Tomatoes
A few studies suggest basil nearby can reduce thrips on tomatoes.
How: Grow basil in pots or gaps beside your tomatoes. Both need warmth and shelter, so it’s an easy pairing to try, and you can keep picking the basil.
Worth knowing: The evidence is thin and not from UK gardens. There’s no good evidence that basil improves the flavour of tomatoes.
What the evidence says
- A few studies show that basil and marigolds can be effective at reducing thrips populations on tomatoes in both field and greenhouse conditions. University of Minnesota Extension
- In a growth-chamber study, basil growing nearby made tomato wound-response genes react faster and more strongly. Pests were not measured, so this is not evidence of pest control. Plant Cell Reports
Limits of the evidence
- An optional experiment: few studies, none in UK gardens, and the size of any effect is unknown.
- We found no measured evidence that basil improves tomato flavour or yield in home gardens.
Garlic with Strawberries
Garlic between strawberry rows reduced two-spotted spider mite in a trial abroad.
How: Plant garlic cloves between strawberry rows in autumn. More garlic gave a bigger effect in the trial, but don’t crowd the strawberries.
Worth knowing: The trial was in Brazil. In the UK, autumn garlic is usually lifted in early summer, so it may be gone before mites build up in hot weather.
What the evidence says
- Garlic intercropped between strawberry rows at three densities, in greenhouse and field, reduced two-spotted spider mite by up to 52%, with the greatest reduction in the field when mite numbers were high. Experimental and Applied Acarology
Limits of the evidence
- An optional experiment: one study, outside the UK, against one pest.
- The effect depended on garlic density; don’t assume it works against other strawberry pests.
Lettuce with Cauliflower
Planting cauliflower into a lettuce crop reduced cabbage root fly eggs in field trials.
How: Plant cauliflower between lettuce that is already growing, then harvest the lettuce soon after so it doesn’t compete.
Worth knowing: In one of the two trial years, a different root fly laid more eggs in the mixed plots and cauliflower yields fell.
What the evidence says
- In both years, fewer cabbage root fly eggs were found on cauliflower relay-cropped with lettuce, with comparable curd size. In 2004, other Delia root flies laid more eggs in the relay crop, and plant losses reduced yields. Journal of Economic Entomology
Limits of the evidence
- An optional experiment: mixed results across pest species and years.
- Mesh or brassica collars remain the reliable protection.
Basil with Aubergines
Basil among aubergines helped predatory lacewings settle and aphids fall faster in a greenhouse study.
How: Grow basil closely among your aubergines under glass; the densest planting worked best in the study.
Worth knowing: The study measured lacewing colonisation in greenhouses; it doesn’t show basil alone brings enough predators into a home greenhouse.
What the evidence says
- Basil improved the fecundity and longevity of the lacewing Chrysopa pallens in the laboratory; in greenhouses, high-density basil intercrops gave the highest lacewing colonisation and the fastest aphid decline. Insects
Limits of the evidence
- An optional experiment: one study, and the lacewings’ presence mattered as much as the basil.
White clover with Leeks and Onions
Undersowing leeks with clover has reduced onion thrips in trials.
How: Sow clover thinly between leek or onion rows once they’re established, and keep it trimmed low.
Worth knowing: Competition from the clover can cancel out the benefit. It didn’t help against allium leaf miner in a UK gardeners’ trial.
What the evidence says
- Leeks undersown with clover have shown excellent potential for onion thrips control, and intercropping onions has cut infestations by at least 50% in some trials; competition and cost may limit usefulness. AHDB
- In a 2024 UK gardeners’ trial, low-growing clover had very little effect on allium leaf miner in leeks. Garden Organic
Limits of the evidence
- An optional experiment: evidence is for onion thrips only, from field-scale trials.
- Watch for competition, especially on young plants.
Worth checking
Tomatoes and potatoes share blight
Late blight is caused by the same organism on both crops, and its spores blow on the wind.
What to do: In warm, wet spells, check both crops for brown patches on leaves and stems. If one shows blight, watch the other closely.
Greenhouse tomatoes are less likely to be reached by windblown spores, though it can still happen through doors and vents.
Protection that works alongside companions
For several pests, physical protection is more reliable than any companion plant.
Cover carrots with insect-proof mesh
Mesh with 1.3–1.4mm holes over the whole crop keeps carrot fly out. Rotate beds, as flies can emerge from soil under the cover.
Why: Carrot fly lays eggs in late May–June and again in August–September.
- Complete covering with insect-proof mesh is more effective than a barrier; maggots hatch from eggs laid in late May–June and August–September. RHS
- Standard 1.3–1.4mm mesh is good for carrot fly. RHS
- Covering with mesh or fleece is more likely to give consistent carrot fly control than growing onions alongside. Garden Organic
Cover alliums with fine mesh while leaf miner is active
Fine mesh (about 0.8mm), with edges buried, keeps allium leaf miner off. Rotate beds, as flies can emerge underneath. Companion plants aren’t a proven alternative.
Why: Adult allium leaf miners are most active in March–April and September–November.
- Insect-proof mesh protects plants when adults are active; peak activity is March–April and September–November; rotate crops. RHS
- Fine 0.8mm mesh suits leaf miners; bury edges at least 5cm. RHS
- In a 2024 UK gardeners’ trial, chard grown with leeks showed a non-significant trend towards less allium leaf miner but cut marketable leek yield by 69%; low-growing clover had very little effect. Garden Organic
Protect young brassicas from root fly and flea beetle
Fit a collar (8–15cm across) around each new transplant’s stem, or grow under insect-proof mesh all season. Mesh also keeps flea beetles off seedlings.
Why: Cabbage root fly maggots are active from April to September and can kill young transplants; flea beetles attack seedlings in spring and summer.
Grow under insect-proof mesh against root fly and flea beetle
Cover the row with insect-proof mesh from sowing, with the edges buried. It keeps cabbage root fly off the roots and flea beetles off the leaves. Rotate beds, as pests can emerge from the soil underneath.
Why: Cabbage root fly maggots tunnel into turnip, swede and radish roots from April to September; flea beetles pepper the leaves of seedlings, rocket and oriental greens in spring and summer.
- Cabbage root fly attacks brassicas, oriental greens, swede, turnip and radish; in root crops the maggots tunnel into the edible roots. Insect-proof mesh or fleece protects plants. RHS
- Flea beetles feed on all brassicas and related plants, including rocket, radish, swede and turnip; seedlings are most at risk, and insect-proof mesh or fleece prevents damage. RHS
Popular claims, checked
“Basil makes tomatoes taste better”
In three years of blind taste tests, tomatoes grown with basil tasted no different. Grow basil because you like it.
- In garden-scale studies over three years, double-blind taste tests showed no consistent preference for tomatoes grown with companions such as basil over tomatoes grown alone. West Virginia University (PhD thesis)
“Marigolds next to tomatoes stop root-knot nematodes”
The effect came from particular marigold varieties grown as a crop before the tomatoes, in California. A few marigolds beside a tomato isn’t the same thing, and these nematodes are rarely a problem in UK gardens.
- In Californian field trials, tomatoes grown after the marigold variety Single Gold had less nematode infestation and root galling, and yielded about 50% more than after fallow. Plant Disease
“Never grow tomatoes and potatoes near each other”
They do share late blight, but its spores blow a long way, so distance within a garden won’t stop it. Check both crops in warm, wet weather instead.
“Marigolds repel all pests”
The good evidence is specific: French marigolds slowed glasshouse whitefly on tomatoes. Studies found they don’t deter other pests such as Colorado potato beetle.
- French marigolds grown alongside glasshouse tomatoes slowed glasshouse whitefly population development. PLOS ONE
- Marigolds are often said to deter Colorado potato beetles, but multiple studies have shown this to be untrue. University of Minnesota Extension
“Marigolds protect potatoes from beetles”
Studies found marigolds don’t deter Colorado potato beetle, and that beetle isn’t established in Great Britain anyway. If you ever see one, report it.
- Marigolds are often said to deter Colorado potato beetles, but multiple studies have shown this to be untrue. University of Minnesota Extension
- Colorado beetle is a notifiable quarantine pest that is not present in Great Britain; suspected sightings must be reported. Defra UK Plant Health Portal
“Onions keep carrot fly away”
Trials have given mixed results, and any effect faded once onions started to bulb. Insect-proof mesh is the reliable protection.
- Onions grown with carrots were thought to confuse carrot root fly, but trials have shown inconsistent results; mesh or fleece is more likely to give consistent control. Garden Organic
- Mixed cropping reduced carrot fly attack only with young onions at high density; the effect was virtually lost once the onions began to bulb. Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata 36:159–167
“Nasturtiums lure cabbage white caterpillars away from brassicas”
Large white caterpillars do eat nasturtiums, but they eat cabbages too, and there’s no good evidence that nasturtiums keep them off. Fine netting and checking for eggs work.
“Rosemary and other strong herbs repel cabbage pests”
Cabbage aphids detected rosemary scent in laboratory tests, but it hasn’t been shown to protect brassicas in gardens or fields. Scent effects are specific to each pest.
- In laboratory olfactometer and antenna tests, cabbage aphids responded to rosemary volatiles; the authors propose rosemary as a potential repellent “push” plant, not yet a proven field treatment. Journal of Chemical Ecology
“Peas and beans feed the plants growing next to them”
Peas and beans fix nitrogen at their roots, but how much passes to neighbours while they grow varies widely and is often small. More reaches the soil as roots and leftovers break down, so leave the roots in after harvest.
- Across 74 studies, the share of a legume’s nitrogen passed to a neighbouring crop during growth ranged from under 1% to about 53%, depending strongly on conditions; fertiliser reduced it. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 401:110295
- As legumes fix nitrogen from the air at their roots, the RHS advises cutting plants down after harvest and leaving the roots in the ground to boost soil nitrogen; its bean guides say the same. RHS
“Companion plants protect leeks from allium leaf miner”
In a 2024 UK gardeners’ trial, chard made no significant difference to leaf miner but cut the leek crop by two-thirds, and clover did very little. Fine mesh works.
- Chard beside leeks showed a non-significant trend towards less allium leaf miner but cut marketable yield by 69%; low-growing clover had very little effect. Garden Organic
- Insect-proof mesh protects plants when adult flies are active. RHS
Companion planting in Sow Time
In the Sow Time app, each crop’s Good neighbours and the garden’s Better together section suggest companions for the crops you’re actually growing. Suggestions take account of the crop’s stage, where it’s growing (a bed, pot, greenhouse or indoors) and whether the companion will be useful in time. Pairings with limited or traditional evidence are shown as optional experiments and are never turned into jobs.
Open Sow Time Free to use, with no account needed. Your garden is saved on your device.
Sources
- Does plant diversity benefit agroecosystems? A synthetic review (Letourneau et al., 2011), Ecological Applications
- The effectiveness of flower strips and hedgerows on pest control, pollination services and crop yield: a quantitative synthesis (Albrecht et al., 2020), Ecology Letters
- Finding guidelines for cabbage intercropping systems design as a first step in a meta-analysis relay for vegetables (2023), Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment
- Can companion planting reduce allium leaf miner? (2024 members’ experiment), Garden Organic
- CIPM3: Companion crop on arable and horticultural land, Defra / GOV.UK
- Companion planting with French marigolds protects tomato plants from glasshouse whiteflies through the emission of airborne limonene (Conboy et al., 2019), PLOS ONE
- How the humble marigold outsmarts a devastating tomato pest, Newcastle University
- Tagetes patula (French marigold), RHS
- Three ways to use companion planting, RHS
- Efficient intercropping for biological control of aphids in transplanted organic lettuce, eOrganic (USDA-ARS research)
- Agronomic aspects of strip intercropping lettuce with alyssum for biological control of aphids (Brennan, 2013), Biological Control
- The effect of within-crop habitat manipulations on the conservation biological control of aphids in field-grown lettuce (Skirvin et al.), Bulletin of Entomological Research
- Lobularia maritima (sweet alyssum), RHS
- Grow it: alyssum, RHS
- Syrphid diversity in sweet alyssum flower strips in Quebec’s lettuce fields (Kalboussi et al., 2025), Ecology and Evolution
- Companion planting to attract pollinators increases the yield and quality of strawberry fruit in gardens and allotments (Griffiths-Lee, Nicholls & Goulson, 2020), Ecological Entomology
- Experimental evidence that wildflower strips increase pollinator visits to crops (Feltham et al., 2015), Ecology and Evolution
- Wildflower strips enhance pollination in adjacent strawberry crops at the small scale (Ganser et al., 2018), Ecology and Evolution
- How to grow borage, RHS
- Aphids on strawberry: cultural and natural control, AHDB
- Creating wildflower meadows, RHS
- Organic gardening, RHS
- Host-plant selection by insects – a theory based on “appropriate/inappropriate landings” by pest insects of cruciferous plants (Finch & Collier, 2000), Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata
- Green manures, RHS
- Living on the edge: using and improving trap crops for flea beetle management in small-scale cropping systems (George, Port & Collier, 2019), Insects
- Flea beetles on brassicas and allied plants, RHS
- Eggplant-garlic intercrops reduce the density of Tetranychus urticae on eggplant and improve crop yield (2023), Experimental and Applied Acarology
- Hoverflies, RHS
- Calendula, RHS
- Hardy annuals: sowing in autumn, RHS
- Companion or mixed planting, Garden Organic
- Carrot fly, RHS
- Effect of mixed cropping on some insect pests of carrots and onions (Uvah & Coaker, 1984), Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata 36:159–167
- Courgette, marrow and squash problems, RHS
- How to grow radishes, RHS
- Three sisters planting, RHS
- Root foraging elicits niche complementarity-dependent yield advantage in the ancient ‘three sisters’ (maize/bean/squash) polyculture (Zhang et al., 2014), Annals of Botany
- Nitrogen transfer in legume/non-legume intercropping systems: a global meta-analysis (Chen et al., 2026), Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 401:110295
- Companion planting in home gardens, University of Minnesota Extension
- Companion basil plants prime the tomato wound response through volatile signaling in a mixed planting system (2024), Plant Cell Reports
- Intercropping garlic plants reduces Tetranychus urticae in strawberry crop (2016), Experimental and Applied Acarology
- Relay cropping cauliflower with lettuce as a means to manage first-generation cabbage maggot and minimize cauliflower yield loss (Parsons, Dixon & Colbo, 2007), Journal of Economic Entomology
- Optimizing the use of basil as a functional plant for the biological control of aphids by Chrysopa pallens in greenhouses (Fang et al., 2022), Insects
- Basic biology and management of onion thrips on field crops, AHDB
- Tomato blight, RHS
- Potato blight, RHS
- Insect-proof mesh, RHS
- Allium leaf miner, RHS
- Cabbage root fly, RHS
- Yield, pest density, and tomato flavor effects of companion planting in garden-scale studies incorporating tomato, basil, and Brussels sprout (Bomford, 2004), West Virginia University (PhD thesis)
- Effects of selected marigold varieties on root-knot nematodes and tomato and melon yields (2002), Plant Disease
- Factsheet: Colorado beetle (Leptinotarsa decemlineata), Defra UK Plant Health Portal
- Growing nasturtiums in a school garden, RHS
- Cabbage caterpillars, RHS
- Electrophysiological and behavioral responses of cabbage aphid (Brevicoryne brassicae) to rosemary (Rosmarinus officinalis) volatiles, a potential push plant (2024), Journal of Chemical Ecology
- How to grow peas, RHS
Sources are paraphrased, not quoted. Follow the links for the full advice.
Evidence last reviewed 1 October 2026. Each claim is paraphrased from the source linked beside it.